A Mean Murder Mystery III

Mean from a table Murder Mystery Miss B

It's been a while since I have last shared a murder mystery. So here is my Harry Potter themed murder mystery. The topic if you haven't guessed it yet is calculating the mean specifically from a table. Everybody loves a play on words, right?

This murder mystery was part of a lesson I did with my year 7's recently, I've wanted to spend the time in creating a good mean from the table lesson for a while. I started with a stopclock starter where students had to calculate the median, mode and range from lists and tables. This warmed the students up and refresh their knowledge of both grouped and ungrouped tables. 

I introduced the murder mystery by asking the students to read the newspaper article which always gets a buzz in the classroom. Following this I displayed the four suspects Professor Snape, Sirus Black, Draco Malfoy and Bellatrix Lestrange. This information card also includes their individual stats. 

Now the fun and games began, After some exploration and mini white board work we were ready to attempt solving the murder mystery. If students completed these quickly I had some challenging exam reasoning questions ready. 

Clues one and two focus on students calculating the mean from an ungrouped frequency table. Students are then tasked with solving clues three and four which are calculating the mean from a grouped table.

Students have to presume that the murderer is the average person. At the end of the mystery we discussed this assumption in depth and  they decided that the murder might only be the average person for some traits or may hold none of the average traits. One student argued "Well the average person doesn't just go around murdering people. So why would the murderer have the average traits." It's interesting to see how the classes logical, problem solving and reasoning minds work when discussing this. 

Clue 1 - Students need to find the mean shoe size of the murderer to be able to rule out one of the four suspects. 

Clue 2 - Students need to find the mean age of the people in attendance to rule out some, but becareful with rounding here. 


Clue 3 - Students need to find the meanheight of the party goers. 

Clue 4 - Students need to confirm their suspicions by calculating the mean weight of the party guests. 

SPOILER ALERT - Answers are at the end of the document

Click here to Download 

Tags: Literacy, Problem Solving, Independent Learning, Investigation, Engagement, murder mystery

Leave your comments

Post comment as a guest

0 / 500 Character restriction
Your text should be in between 10-500 characters
  • No comments found

Related Articles

The Take Away Lesson This is a great way to get pupils enthused and hooked in the lesson. It’s your choice whether you use just one aspect of... Teaching and Learning
Maths Murder Mystery After a long, fun and rewarding weekend away with year 9 students to develop their Numeracy and Literacy skills alongs... Teaching and Learning
Independent Learning TheoryIndependent learning is buzz term that has been around for several years within education but what is it all about... Teaching and Learning
Stretching the Challenge In light of this coming weeks AGSInspire, I thought I would write my own views on stretching the challenge for all stude... Teaching and Learning

“Miss B is always coming up with great new ideas. I have been delighted to work with her on linking numeracy and literacy”

Simon Blower 
Simon Blower
Co Founder of pobble.com


“Makes Maths interesting, relevant and accessible.”

Mark Anderson 
Mark Anderson
Author of ‘Perfect ICT Every Lesson’ and international speaker.


“Maths teachers looking for inspiration and quality resources? Look no further than @MissBsResources.” 

Jon Tait
Jon Tait
Olympic torch bearer, deputy head teacher and international speaker.


Danielle Bartram

Maths Lead Practitioner

Acklam Grange School